A post-rock lover’s guide to Classical music: Russian cycles, part 3
Sergei Prokofiev
[Still waiting to be reunited with my CD collection! So this episode is not exactly centered on a particular work, but rather on Prokofiev himself. There are a few suggestions below, of course.]
Prokofiev, Symphony n.5, 1st movement (download)—————–
My love affair with Prokofiev started by chance, and it happened after years of not really listening to a lot Classical music. I caught a movement of his first piano concerto on the radio and I was immediately won over by the newness of his language, the way the melody could sound so fresh and exciting, going to places you wouldn’t expect it to go, while still being strongly anchored in a clear tonal system. That moment literally opened up a whole new perspective on musical ideas, in a way very few musical works have ever since.
Years of listening to as much Prokofiev as I could showed me that that single concerto was no fluke. When you become really familiar with a particular band’s style, you develop a bond with the records, the sound of the guitars, the particular inflections of certain riffs and hooks. Godspeed just sounds like Godspeed, 65 Days of Static just sounds like 65 Days of Static, and so on…You could try to put this intimate knowledge into words, but you’d be missing the easiest description: their music speaks for itself.
Prokofiev flirted with atonality as a student at the turn of the Century, but never really embraced it. He did however create a language that is extremely articulate and nuanced. He understood how texture can suggest sarcasm and irony to a particular scene in a way few composers did. Listen to the more lighthearted passages in Romeo and Juliet or his Love for Three Oranges: comedy is rarely so obvious in music.
As most composers of the first half of the Twentieth Century, Prokofiev was deeply affected by the atrocities of his time. His Fifth Symphony was hailed as the unofficial soundtrack to the end of World War II, as it celebrated the hard-fought victory of the Red Army against the Germans on the Russian Front, which would eventually lead to Hitler’s downfall in the East. Listen to the first movement (which you can download here) and it isn’t hard to imagine the state Prokofiev was in. A victory of this magnitude doesn’t come for free, and the music mourns the fallen as much as it celebrates their courage.
Much like his friend Shostakovitch, Prokofiev was a witness of the Twentieth Century, through its achievements, its victories but also its struggles and its losses. Both composers enjoyed relative freedom from the Communist Party doctrines on cultural productions, while remaining attached to their native land. They enjoyed tremendous success in the West, but in their hearts, they remained Russian to the end.
Joseph Stalin died on March 5th, 1953. In a rigid regime like the one he helped creating, the death of the leader was an unprecedented national event, followed by days of mourning. The country literally stopped, and Moscow was at a standstill during the whole week leading up to his funeral. Deaths like these only happen a few times in a Century.
Oddly enough, Prokofiev died the same day, in the same city.
—————–
Among Prokofiev’s five piano concertos, I find his first one to be the most interesting, in a way. It clearly sounds like the product of a young mind, brash, bold and tentative at the same time. While not the most popular of his works, there are moments of ecstatic beauty in this relatively short concerto. It is a technically demanding piece, which displays Prokofiev’s own pianistic skills, but even as a student showpiece, it already contains the main elements of his unique musical language.
This live version by Martha Argerich is formidable, as she always is.
1st movement
———————-
2nd movement
———————-
3rd movement
———————-
Peter and the Wolf is one of the mainstays of music composed for children, and it’s easy to see why. Prokofiev thoroughly enjoyed the process and the objective of this commission piece, as he took only four days to complete the story and score.
As an introduction to the different voices and textures of an orchestra, Peter and the Wolf brilliantly puts the various sounds into a coherent narrative whole, which emphasizes the dramatic connotation we put on some instruments.
Let’s face it: could Darth Vader be represented by anything other than trombones and tubas?
The stop-motion Oscar winning version by Suzie Templeton takes some liberties with the original story, but she manages to recreate the fears of a child, in a way most child-friendly programs avoid. Genuine, cathartic fear, like a story by the Brothers Grimm. My children love it, and are both rightly elated and scared by it, as it should be.
———————-
———————-
———————-
———————-
———————-











